Resistive or capacitive: Choosing
the right touchscreen phone
The basic difference between the two is in the way they
respond to the touch of your finger.
There was a
time when people used to have the same mobile phone for years together but that
has changed now. According to a recent survey, most users now change their mobile phone
every two years.
But buying a
mobile phone is still not easy. To make an informed decision, you must be aware
of the various features, and especially those of the display, which constitutes
a very important part of phones today.
Basically,
there are two types of touchscreen displays -- resistive and capacitive. The
experience of using each is quite different, so we suggest you understand the
basics of both before troubling your wallet.
Resistive vs
capacitive
The basic
difference between resistive and capacitive technologies is in the way they
respond to the touch of your finger or stylus.
Resistive touchscreens are made of several layers, the
topmost of which flexes under your finger or stylus, and is pushed back to
touch a layer below it. This completes a circuit, telling the phone which part
of the screen is being pressed.
Capacitive
touchscreens don't rely on pressure, and instead use electrodes to sense the
conductive properties of your finger. So they don't rely on having an object
pressing particularly hard on their surface, and react only to touch of your
finger.
User experience
The type of
touchscreen can easily be recognised by the user.
Capacitive
screens don't require the user to press hard to initiate an action; a light
swipe across the screen usually produces the desired action, such as scrolling
through contact lists or photos etc, zooming in and out of web pages and maps,
and typing emails and text messages.
Capacitive
technology also often supports multi touch so that it can detect more than one
finger at once. This can be used for advanced gestures such as pinch to zoom,
as on iPhone or Android devices.
In contrast to
capacitive touch, a vast majority of resistive touchscreen phones won't
normally react at all to a very light swipe -- the user has to exert some
pressure to initiate action.
While it may
sound as if capacitive touch is the best choice, that's not entirely correct.
Resistive offers more potential for accuracy when used with a stylus, while
capacitive touchscreens can only be touched with a finger. They don't respond
to touches with a regular stylus, gloves or other objects, though special
touchscreen styluses are available.
Which
touchscreen technology is better?
The general
consensus among smartphone users is that a capacitive touchscreen is the way to
go, but one thing that needs to be kept in mind is that capacitive screens,
being made of glass, are more susceptible to damage by sharp objects such as
coins, keys, scissors, tweezers, pens and so on, which invariably give your
cell phone company in handbags and pockets. In the case of a resistive
touchscreen, on the other hand, you can buy skin guards, which will make the
device less responsive, but will still work. The same solution in the
capacitive screens costs much more, as it requires special screen guards with
metal insert. Also the other good news is that most of the high end capacitive
touch screen phones comes with Gorilla glass or similar technologies which
prevent scratches.
Touchscreen
smartphones
The best
capacitive touchscreen phones available in the market today include Apple's
iPhone 4, HTC Sensation, Motorola Razr, Sony Ericsson Xperia Arc S and Samsung
Galaxy series handsets. Barring Apple's devices, which run on iOS, the
others use Android operating systems.
For a resistive
touchscreen from the Android family, you could consider Micromax A60, Dell
XCD28 and Samsung Galaxy POP.
In you are
looking for a touchscreen phone which will work on Symbian
you can have a look at Samsung Omnia HD and Nokia N8, both of which have
capacitive touchscreens. For a resistive screen, you could get either Nokia N97
or Nokia 5800 Express Music.
Alternatively,
you can explore proprietary OS phones as well. Samsung Jet, LG KS360 and LG
Cookie are good resistive touchscreen devices; and LG Crystal, LG Viewty Smart
and Samsung Wave 3 are among the better capacitive screen devices running
operating systems owned by their respective producers.
Latest
development
Toshiba has brought
a new technology that combines the benefits of both capacitive and resistive
touchscreens, while negating their limitations.
The technology
was showcased recently at the Embedded World Conference in Nurnberg, Germany.
Touchscreens
used in smartphones are generally capacitive, which allow dual touch gestures
but do not respond to a pen, gloved hands or stylus. Resistive touchscreens do
the opposite; they accept pen, stylus and gloved inputs but multi touch does
not work well on these screens.
Toshiba's
touchscreens accept multi point touch gestures to allow users better control
over their computing devices.
If you’re after a new phone, there’s a good chance the one you wind up with
will have a touchscreen. More and more often, new phones feature them these
days, and if you’re on a higher-end contract, contact with them is virtually
inescapable.However, if you’re planning on giving into the touchscreen trend, there are a few important things to consider. The most important of these is that there are actually two types of touchscreen predominantly used in phones – resistive and capacitive. The experience of using the two is quite different, so we’d recommend getting clued up on the two technologies before taking the plunge in either direction.
How they work
The main reason they’re quite so different to use is that the way they register the presence of your finger and its prods are poles apart. Resistive technology works the way you might first imagine a touchscreen would function – it senses pressure.
The resistive touchscreen itself is made up of several layers, the topmost of which flexes under your finger or stylus, and is pushed back onto a layer behind it. This effectively completes a circuit, telling the phone which part of the screen is being pressed.
Capacitive touchscreens don’t rely on pressure, but rather they use electrodes to sense the conductive properties of objects, such as your finger. So, they don’t rely on having an object pressing particularly hard on their surface, but will only react to certain objects. Prod one with a standard stylus and you’ll get nowhere.
In Practice
Thanks to these core differences, the experience of using each type of touchscreen is almost instantly recognisable. The most famous phone of the last couple of years, Apple’s iPhone, uses a capacitive touchscreen, which helps to give the phone its ‘light touch’ interface.
As capacitive screens don’t need much contact at all, you can swipe across them very lightly and get just as good a response as you would with a slow, full-fingered drag. By comparison, the vast majority of resistive touchscreen phones won’t normally react at all to a very light swipe.
More recent resistive touchscreen phones, such as the Nokia N97, HTC Tattoo and Samsung Jet have made their resisitive touchscreens much more sensitive than those of previous years, helping to bridge the gap between the two technologies, but we’re yet to see a resistive touchscreen that convinced us it was capacitive for any length of time. Using a finger, capacitive screens will seem much more responsive.
So, it may sound like a capacitive touchscreen is the way to go, without any doubt, but things aren’t quite that simple – resistive touchscreens have their benefits too.
The simplest is that they don’t rely on the organic properties of your finger, so can be operated with just about anything – just not necessarily successfully. A more important plus point of resistive screens is that they offer more potential for accuracy.
If you try to operate a either sort of touchscreen phone with your finger, accuracy will fly out of the window, but use a resistive phone with a stylus and you’ll be able to get relative pinpoint accuracy.
< previous 1 2 next >
Comments
Post a Comment